Water Filtration vs. Purification Tablets: What’s Safest for International Overlanding in 2026?

Table of Contents

Crossing into remote borderlands where the nearest hospital is three days away changes your relationship with water. That crystal-clear stream bubbling from a Himalayan glacier or the village well in the Sahel might look pristine, but in 2026’s rapidly changing environment, appearances deceive more than ever. For international overlanders—those self-reliant travelers who carry their world on four wheels—water safety isn’t just another checklist item; it’s the difference between the trip of a lifetime and a medevac nightmare.

The debate between filtration and purification tablets has evolved far beyond simple weight-versus-convenience calculations. Today’s overlanding routes traverse regions experiencing unprecedented water stress, emerging pathogens, and industrial contamination that older treatment methods weren’t designed to handle. As you plan your 2026 expedition from Patagonia to Mongolia, understanding the nuanced strengths and critical limitations of each approach isn’t optional—it’s survival science.

The Overlanding Water Challenge in 2026

Why Water Safety is Your Top Priority

When your vehicle becomes your home for months across multiple continents, water sourcing transforms from a casual campsite chore into a daily risk assessment. Unlike backpackers who can often plan around known water sources, overlanders frequently find themselves filling tanks from questionable municipal taps, agricultural runoff-fed rivers, or wells of unknown quality. The sheer volume of water needed—often 5-10 liters per person daily for drinking, cooking, and hygiene—amplifies any contamination risk exponentially.

The consequences of getting it wrong have never been higher. Antibiotic-resistant bacteria are proliferating globally, meaning that traveler’s diarrhea that sidelined you for 48 hours in 2018 could now trigger a serious infection requiring IV treatment in a region where medical facilities are scarce or substandard. Your water treatment system is quite literally your health insurance policy.

The Evolving Threat Landscape

Climate change has redrawn the water safety map. Droughts concentrate pollutants in shrinking water sources, while flooding overwhelms sanitation infrastructure and spreads pathogens across watersheds. Permafrost melt in Arctic overlanding routes is releasing ancient microbes and heavy metals previously locked in ice. Meanwhile, rapid development in previously remote areas introduces industrial chemicals and pharmaceutical residues into water supplies that were once reliably pure.

In 2026, we’re also seeing the emergence of “super protozoa” like chlorine-resistant Giardia strains in certain regions, and viruses that can survive longer in warmer waters. The old rule of thumb—“fast-flowing mountain streams are safe”—is dangerously outdated.

Understanding Water Contamination: What You’re Up Against

Biological Threats: Bacteria, Viruses, and Protozoa

Waterborne pathogens fall into three categories, each requiring different treatment approaches. Bacteria like E. coli, Salmonella, and Campylobacter are the most common culprits behind acute gastrointestinal illness. They’re relatively large (0.2-5 microns) and generally susceptible to both filtration and chemical treatment.

Viruses—hepatitis A, norovirus, rotavirus—are far smaller (0.02-0.1 microns) and can slip through most filters designed for backcountry use. They’re your primary concern in developing regions with poor sanitation, where human waste contaminates water sources. Chemical purification excels here, while basic filtration fails.

Protozoa, including Giardia and Cryptosporidium, occupy a middle ground. Their cysts are large enough for good filters to catch (5-15 microns) but their protective walls can resist chemical treatment, especially in cold or turbid water. Cryptosporidium is particularly notorious; its oocysts can survive chlorine concentrations that kill everything else.

Chemical and Heavy Metal Contaminants

Here’s where the filtration versus purification debate gets serious. Purification tablets do nothing to remove arsenic leaching from bedrock in parts of Asia, lead from old pipes in historic European towns, or agricultural pesticides in Central American water sources. Industrial solvents, mining runoff, and forever chemicals (PFAS) are increasingly common in global water supplies.

Only activated carbon filtration or more advanced media can adsorb these contaminants. If your route includes areas with known industrial activity, aging infrastructure, or volcanic geology, chemical purification alone leaves you vulnerable to long-term health effects that won’t manifest until you’re home.

Emerging Concerns for 2026 and Beyond

Microplastic contamination has become ubiquitous, with particles now found in remote mountain lakes and desert oases alike. While health impacts are still being studied, filtration systems with fine enough pores (0.1 microns or less) can remove most particles. Algal blooms, intensified by warming waters, produce cyanotoxins that require both filtration and chemical treatment to neutralize fully.

Perhaps most concerning for overlanders is the rise of “treatment-resistant” pathogens in regions with heavy tourist traffic. When thousands of trekkers use Aquatabs in the same watershed, local microbes adapt. Rotation between treatment methods may become necessary in popular overlanding corridors.

Water Filtration Systems: Your First Line of Defense

How Mechanical Filtration Actually Works

Filtration is a physical process—think of it as a super-fine sieve. Water is forced through a matrix of hollow fibers, ceramic, or other media with microscopic pores. The “micron rating” determines what gets through. A 0.1-micron absolute filter catches bacteria and protozoa but lets viruses pass. A 0.02-micron filter can theoretically catch viruses but clogs rapidly in real-world conditions.

The key term is “absolute” versus “nominal.” Absolute means guaranteed; nominal means “mostly.” For overlanding where health stakes are high, absolute-rated filters are non-negotiable. Look for NSF/ANSI Standard 53 or 58 certification, which verifies performance claims under real-world conditions.

Types of Overlanding-Friendly Filters

Pump Filters offer reliability and control. You can source water from shallow puddles or trickling seeps, and the pumping action forces water through the filter element. The downside? They’re labor-intensive for large volumes and have multiple seals and moving parts that can fail in dusty conditions.

Gravity Systems shine for basecamp-style overlanding. Fill a dirty reservoir, hang it from your roof rack, and let physics do the work while you set up camp. They’re low-effort but require a decent water source depth and are useless for quick roadside fill-ups.

Squeeze Filters combine portability with reasonable flow rates. Attach them to a flexible bottle or hydration bladder and squeeze. They’re perfect for personal drinking water but tedious for filling a 40-liter vehicle tank.

In-line and Vehicle-Mounted Systems represent the gold standard for serious overlanders. These plumbed systems filter water as you pump it into your vehicle’s storage tank, treating large volumes with minimal effort. However, they require installation, power, and become a single point of failure for your entire water supply.

Filtration Limitations You Must Know

No filter removes viruses reliably in field conditions. Even those claiming viral protection clog quickly with sediment, organic matter, or biofilm. Filters also don’t remove dissolved chemicals or heavy metals unless they include substantial activated carbon stages. Most importantly, filters can fail catastrophically—a cracked filter element from a freeze-thaw cycle or a compromised O-ring can let contaminated water pass through without any visual indication.

Filter maintenance in the field is another critical gap. Backflushing requires clean water, which you might not have. Ceramic filters can be scrubbed, but hollow fiber filters have limited lifespans measured in hundreds or thousands of liters, and tracking usage across a multi-month expedition is challenging.

Purification Tablets: The Chemical Solution

The Science Behind Chemical Purification

Purification tablets work by introducing a disinfectant—typically chlorine, iodine, or chlorine dioxide—that disrupts pathogen cell walls or interferes with their metabolism. The key variables are concentration and contact time. Too little chemical or too little time, and you get incomplete sterilization. Too much, and you’re drinking a chemistry experiment.

Chlorine dioxide tablets are the current standard for comprehensive protection. They kill bacteria, viruses, and most protozoa (though Cryptosporidium requires extended contact time). Unlike chlorine, they don’t create trihalomethanes (THMs) when reacting with organic matter, and they leave minimal taste.

Common Tablet Types and Their Effectiveness

Chlorine-based tablets (calcium hypochlorite) are cheap and widely available globally. They’re effective against bacteria and viruses but struggle with Giardia and fail against Cryptosporidium. They also produce a distinct “pool water” taste and can create harmful byproducts in turbid water.

Iodine tablets, once the backpacker standard, have fallen out of favor. They’re less effective against Cryptosporidium, unsuitable for pregnant women or people with thyroid issues, and leave a nasty taste. Their advantage is extreme shelf life and reliability.

Chlorine dioxide tablets offer the broadest spectrum of effectiveness. They kill all major pathogens, work in relatively turbid water, and have manageable taste issues. However, they’re more expensive and require 30-minute to 4-hour contact times depending on water temperature and target pathogen.

The Waiting Game: Contact Time Realities

This is where tablets clash with overlanding realities. A 4-hour wait for Cryptosporidium protection means filling your water tank at night and hoping it’s ready by morning. In practice, most travelers don’t wait long enough, especially when thirsty after a long driving day. Cold water dramatically slows chemical reactions—at 4°C (39°F), contact times can double or triple.

Turbidity is another killer. Chemicals can’t penetrate particles of sediment where pathogens hide. You’ll need to pre-filter or let water settle, adding another step when you’re already exhausted from border crossings and broken trails.

The Critical Distinction: Filtration vs. Purification

What Filtration Misses (And Why It Matters)

A standard 0.1-micron filter is a bacterial and protozoan fortress but a viral turnstile. In regions with poor sanitation—think parts of Central Asia, rural Africa, or the Indian subcontinent—viral contamination is your primary threat. Drinking 40 liters of virus-laden water over a week, even with a filter, is playing pathogen roulette.

Filters also miss dissolved contaminants. That arsenic-laden groundwater in parts of Vietnam or the lead pipes in a historic Moroccan medina will pass right through. The health effects are insidious: cognitive impairment, kidney damage, or neurological issues that appear months later.

What Tablets Can’t Remove

Chemical purification is a one-trick pony: it kills living organisms. It does nothing for heavy metals, pesticides, industrial chemicals, or that lovely diesel sheen you sometimes see near marinas. In fact, by adding chemicals to already contaminated water, you might be creating new toxic compounds.

Tablets also can’t improve taste, smell, or appearance. That sulfurous spring water or sediment-laden river will still be unpalatable, potentially limiting your hydration in hot climates. Overlanders need to drink more than backpackers—dehydration while driving is dangerous.

The Redundancy Principle

Here’s the non-negotiable truth for 2026: neither method alone is sufficient for international overlanding. The gold standard is a two-stage approach: filtration first to remove sediment, protozoa, bacteria, and chemical contaminants, followed by chemical purification to eliminate viruses and anything that slipped through. This redundancy covers the weaknesses of each method and provides backup if one system fails.

Overlanding-Specific Considerations for 2026

Vehicle-Based Systems vs. Portable Solutions

Your vehicle’s water system fundamentally changes the equation. A built-in tank with an in-line filter allows you to treat large volumes at once, perfect for remote desert crossings where you need to carry 100+ liters. But what happens when you reach a city and the only water source is a suspect municipal tap? Portable systems provide flexibility but can’t handle the volume for vehicle tanks.

Smart overlanders run hybrid setups: a vehicle-mounted system for bulk water, plus portable filters and tablets for backup and personal bottles. Consider your route’s water availability. In the Sahara, you’ll carry everything; in the Andes, you’ll refill daily from different sources, requiring adaptable treatment.

Group Size and Water Volume Demands

Solo overlanders can get away with lightweight squeeze filters and tablets. A couple might manage with gravity systems. But a family of four on a year-long Pan-American journey needs to process 40+ liters daily. Pumping that by hand is unsustainable. This is where vehicle-mounted systems or large-capacity gravity filters become essential.

Tablets scale linearly with volume—more water needs more chemicals and longer waits. For large groups, this becomes logistically challenging. You’ll need multiple containers in rotation, careful tracking of contact times, and discipline to not dip into water before it’s ready.

Regional Water Quality Variations

Your route dictates your risk profile. In Patagonia, glacial silt and cattle grazing contamination mean filtration is critical, but viral threats are low. In the Ganges basin, viral contamination is extreme, but sediment is minimal. West Africa’s water sources often combine high turbidity, bacterial load, and chemical contamination from mining.

Research your specific route’s contamination profile. The WHO’s Global Water Pathogen Project publishes regional pathogen prevalence maps. Local overlanding forums often have recent water quality intel. A system that’s overkill for Scandinavia might be inadequate for Central Asia.

Building a Redundant Water Safety System

The Two-Stage Treatment Approach

The most reliable protocol for 2026: Stage 1—Pre-filter through an absolute 0.1-micron filter with activated carbon stage to remove sediment, bacteria, protozoa, and chemical contaminants. Stage 2—Add chlorine dioxide tablets to the filtered water and wait the full recommended time (30 minutes for bacteria/viruses, 4 hours for Cryptosporidium if suspected).

This approach covers all bases. If your filter fails, the tablets still protect against pathogens. If you run out of tablets, the filter still removes the most common threats. For high-risk sources, boil the water after both treatments as a third stage.

When to Use Which Method

Use filtration alone only when you’re certain of the water source’s origin (mountain spring above human habitation), the region has excellent sanitation, and you’ve verified no industrial activity upstream. This is rare on international routes.

Use tablets alone as a last resort when filters clog, break, or when treating small volumes of clear water from low-risk areas. Never rely on tablets alone for your primary vehicle water supply.

Boil as backup when both systems fail or when treating water for infants, elderly, or immunocompromised travelers. Boiling kills everything but doesn’t remove chemicals or heavy metals.

Performance Factors That Make or Break Your System

Flow Rate and Convenience Factors

In overlanding, time is often your most limited resource. A filter that produces 1 liter per minute means 40 minutes of pumping to fill your tank. Gravity systems might take 2-3 hours for the same volume. Vehicle-mounted systems with 12V pumps can deliver 10+ liters per minute, but require power and maintenance.

Consider the “hassle factor.” After a 10-hour driving day on corrugated roads, will you realistically pump water for an hour? Systems that integrate into your vehicle’s existing setup (using your water transfer pump) dramatically increase compliance with treatment protocols.

Shelf Life and Storage Considerations

Tablets have expiration dates, typically 2-5 years from manufacture. Heat accelerates degradation—storing them in your vehicle’s glove box in the Sahara can render them useless in months. Keep tablets in their original packaging, in a cool, dark container, and rotate stock annually.

Filters have no expiration but can grow mold if stored wet. After your trip, flush with chlorinated water and air dry completely before storage. Freeze-thaw cycles destroy hollow fiber filters; if you’re overlanding in winter or crossing high-altitude passes, ensure your filter never freezes with water inside.

Cold Weather Performance Challenges

Both systems struggle in extreme cold. Filters can ice internally, cracking the element. Chemical reactions slow to a crawl below 4°C (39°F). In Arctic or high-altitude overlanding, you may need to warm water to near room temperature before treatment. Some overlanders keep their tablet supply in an inside pocket to maintain body heat.

Consider insulating your vehicle’s water system and storing treatment chemicals inside the heated cabin rather than in external boxes. Pre-filtering through a cloth to remove ice crystals helps prevent filter damage.

Maintenance and Longevity in the Field

Filter Maintenance on Extended Trips

A filter rated for 2,000 liters sounds adequate until you’re three months into a trip and realize you’ve processed 1,800 liters of silty river water. Tracking usage is essential—some overlanders log liters in their trip journal or mark their vehicle’s odometer at each filter change.

Backflushing is critical but requires clean water. In practice, you’ll use treated water from your own supply, creating a Catch-22. Carry a spare filter element; they’re cheaper than a medical evacuation. Learn to recognize the signs of filter failure: sudden increase in flow rate (indicating a breach) or complete clogging.

Tablet Degradation and Storage

Tablets are sensitive to moisture and heat. Once opened, most manufacturers recommend using them within months. The packaging is designed to be moisture-proof; transferring tablets to other containers is risky. In humid tropics, consider vacuum-sealing opened packets.

Carry tablets in multiple locations—some in your vehicle, some in your backpack, some in your medical kit. If one batch is compromised, you have backups. Date every package with a permanent marker when you purchase it.

Cost Analysis and Accessibility

Upfront vs. Long-Term Investment

A quality portable filter ($80-150) plus a year’s supply of tablets ($50-100) costs less than a single night in many international hospitals. Vehicle-mounted systems ($300-800) seem expensive until you calculate the cost per liter over a 50,000-kilometer expedition.

Tablets are consumables; costs add up on long trips. A couple using 8 liters daily will go through a $15 packet of tablets every 2-3 weeks. Over a year, that’s $250-300 in tablets alone. Filters have higher upfront costs but process thousands of liters before replacement.

Sourcing Supplies Internationally

Here’s a critical 2026 consideration: supply chain reliability. That specific filter element or tablet brand might be unavailable in Ushuaa or Ulaanbaatar. Western brands command premium prices in developing countries when available. Plan to carry all replacement filters and at least a 3-month tablet supply.

Generic chlorine-based tablets are widely available globally as water treatment for households, but concentrations vary. If you must source locally, verify the active ingredient percentage and adjust dosage accordingly—getting this wrong risks under-treatment or chemical overdose.

Environmental and Health Impact Considerations

Waste and Leave No Trace Principles

Tablets produce packaging waste—blister packs, foil packets, plastic bottles. On a long expedition, this adds up. Some overlanders repackage tablets into reusable vials, but this risks moisture contamination and dosage errors.

Filters eventually become waste. Hollow fiber elements can’t be recycled; ceramic elements can be cleaned but eventually crack. Consider the environmental cost of your chosen system, especially in regions without waste management infrastructure. Avoid single-use filter cartridges when possible.

Chemical Byproducts and Taste Issues

Chlorine reacting with organic matter creates trihalomethanes, suspected carcinogens. This is less of a concern with chlorine dioxide but still worth noting. Iodine tablets can cause thyroid problems with prolonged use—limit iodine to short-term emergency use only.

Taste is a safety issue. If water is unpalatable, you’ll drink less, leading to dehydration. Activated carbon stages in filters improve taste, as does adding vitamin C after the contact time (but only after, as vitamin C neutralizes the disinfectant). Some overlanders add a pinch of salt or a splash of juice to improve palatability.

Real-World Scenarios: Making the Right Choice

High-Risk Regions Requiring Maximum Protection

Picture overlanding the Pamir Highway in Tajikistan. You’re filling from irrigation canals shared by livestock and villages, at altitude where boiling is inefficient. Here, the two-stage approach is mandatory: filter for sediment and parasites, tablets for viruses, and possibly boiling as a third stage. No shortcuts.

In urban South Asia, where municipal water may be treated but distribution pipes are compromised, you’re dealing with both bacterial recontamination and chemical pollutants. A filter with activated carbon plus tablets covers both threats. Never trust hotel or restaurant water without treating it yourself.

Remote Wilderness with Clear Water Sources

In the Canadian Arctic or Scandinavian wilderness, you’re primarily concerned with protozoa from wildlife. A quality filter alone may suffice, but carry tablets as backup for when you encounter human habitation or suspect wildlife die-offs. The redundancy principle still applies—glaciers can harbor ancient pathogens released by melting ice.

In the Australian Outback, where water sources are rare and often stagnant, you’ll face high bacterial loads and potential agricultural runoff. Filter for volume, tablets for viral insurance, and consider the psychological benefit of clear, good-tasting water in a harsh environment.

Expert Recommendations for 2026 Overlanders

The Hybrid Approach: Best Practice Protocol

For international overlanding in 2026, adopt this protocol: 1) Pre-filter all water through a cloth to remove sediment and debris. 2) Run through your primary filter (0.1-micron absolute with carbon). 3) Add chlorine dioxide tablets at the correct dosage. 4) Wait the full contact time, agitating occasionally. 5) Store in a clean, sealed container. 6) For high-risk sources or when treating water for vulnerable individuals, boil for 1 minute (3 minutes above 2,000m elevation) after chemical treatment.

This protocol addresses the weaknesses of each method and provides multiple safety nets. It’s time-consuming but non-negotiable in high-risk regions.

Building Your Water Safety Kit

Your kit should include: a primary filter system appropriate for your vehicle setup, a backup portable filter, a 3-month supply of chlorine dioxide tablets in multiple packages, pre-filter cloths or coffee filters, a collapsible container for settling water, a permanent marker for dating supplies, and printed treatment instructions (when you’re sick and dehydrated, you won’t remember dosages).

Include a simple water testing kit—test strips for chlorine residual and turbidity. If you can’t detect chlorine after treatment, your tablets may be compromised. A TDS (total dissolved solids) meter helps identify chemical contamination that filters and tablets miss entirely.

Common Mistakes That Compromise Safety

Assumptions That Get Overlanders Sick

The most dangerous assumption is that “clear water is safe water.” Viruses and dissolved chemicals are invisible. Another fatal error is trusting local advice without verification—“everyone drinks from this well” means locals have immunity you lack. Never assume a source is safe based on appearance or local habits.

Underestimating contact time is epidemic among overlanders. That “30-minute” tablet treatment becomes 15 minutes because you’re thirsty, or you forget to account for cold water temperatures. Set a timer on your phone for every batch. Treating water while driving is a good way to pass the time and ensure full contact time.

Maintenance Errors in Harsh Conditions

Failing to backflush filters in silty conditions leads to premature clogging and potential element rupture from over-pressurization. Not protecting filters from freezing destroys them overnight. Storing tablets in hot vehicle compartments reduces effectiveness.

Perhaps most common is continuing to use a filter after its lifespan. That “2,000-liter” rating assumes clear water. Processing muddy water might reduce life to 500 liters. When in doubt, replace early. The cost of a new element is trivial compared to illness.

Future-Proofing Your Water Strategy

Innovations on the Horizon

By 2026, we’re seeing promising developments in point-of-use UV-C LED systems that are vehicle-power-friendly and effective against all pathogens. However, they require clear water and battery power—still not standalone solutions. Nanofiber filters promise viral removal without the clogging issues of current membranes, but field durability remains unproven.

Smart overlanders keep an eye on emerging tech but don’t bet their health on unproven gear. Wait for independent testing and real-world expedition reports before adopting new systems.

Climate Change Adaptations

As water sources become less predictable, overlanders must adapt. This means carrying larger water reserves (requiring more treatment capacity), being prepared for more contaminated sources during droughts, and understanding that flooding events can compromise previously reliable springs.

Consider routes with climate resilience. High-altitude sources may be more reliable than lowland rivers in drought-prone regions. Build flexibility into your water strategy—carry both high-volume and portable systems to adapt to changing conditions.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Can I rely solely on purification tablets for a year-long overlanding trip?

No. While tablets effectively kill pathogens, they don’t remove chemical contaminants, heavy metals, or sediment. For long-term international travel, you need filtration plus chemical treatment to address the full spectrum of water threats.

2. How do I know when my filter has reached the end of its lifespan?

Monitor flow rate decline and track total liters processed. When flow becomes noticeably slower despite backflushing, or if you detect any change in water taste/smell, replace the element. For critical applications, replace at 75% of rated capacity to maintain safety margins.

3. Are there any water sources safe enough to drink untreated while overlanding?

Extremely few. Only pristine springs at high altitude, well above any human or animal activity, might qualify. However, with climate change releasing ancient pathogens and wildlife diseases increasing, even these sources carry some risk. Always treat water when overlanding internationally.

4. What’s the best way to treat water for cooking and washing dishes?

For cooking, treat water as you would for drinking—pathogens can survive boiling if not heated long enough. For dishwashing, filtered water is generally sufficient if dishes air-dry completely. In high-risk areas, add a chlorine dioxide tablet to your rinse water.

5. How do altitude and temperature affect purification tablet effectiveness?

Cold water below 4°C (39°F) can double or triple required contact times. Altitude doesn’t directly affect chemical efficacy but impacts boiling points and human hydration needs. Always check tablet instructions for temperature-specific guidance and extend contact times conservatively in cold conditions.

6. Can I use purification tablets in my vehicle’s water tank?

Yes, but with caveats. Tablets work best in small volumes where you can ensure proper mixing. For large tanks, you’ll need to calculate dosage carefully and ensure even distribution by agitating the tank. Contact times remain the same regardless of container size.

7. What should I do if I run out of tablets or my filter breaks in a remote area?

Boiling is your fallback—bring water to a rolling boil for 1 minute (3 minutes above 2,000m). If you can’t boil, solar disinfection (SODIS) works in sunny conditions: fill clear bottles, shake to oxygenate, and leave in direct sun for 6+ hours. This kills most pathogens but is unreliable in cloudy weather.

8. How do I handle water treatment when crossing multiple international borders with different water qualities?

Treat every new water source as high-risk until proven otherwise. Border regions often have compromised infrastructure. Keep detailed logs of where you source water and any illness symptoms. Consider treating water more aggressively for 48 hours after crossing into regions with poorer sanitation.

9. Are there any health conditions that make chemical purification unsafe?

Pregnant women, people with thyroid conditions, and those with G6PD deficiency should avoid iodine-based treatments. Chlorine dioxide is generally safe but consult your doctor before extended use. Infants and immunocompromised individuals need the highest level of protection—use filtration, chemical treatment, and boiling.

10. How do I dispose of used filter elements and tablet packaging responsibly in countries without recycling?

Pack out all filter elements and chemical packaging in double-sealed bags. These materials can contaminate local waste streams and water sources. Consider the total environmental impact when choosing systems—durable, long-life filters generate less waste than frequently replaced cartridges, despite higher initial resource use.